Caddie Picks: How they fared at the Tour Championship

By T.J. Auclair · September 23, 2018

Share this

Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email

1^st: 6
2^nd: 6
3^rd: 2
4^th: 2
5^th: 1
6^th: 9
7^th: 5
8^th: 3
9^th: 2
10^th: 1

Here’s a look at how all the caddie picks have made out this season (WD = Withdrawal; MC = Missed Cut; DNS = Did Not Start; MDF = Made Cut, Did Not Finish):

Tour Championship:

The comeback is complete.

Tiger Woods, hampered by injuries the last several seasons, won the Tour Championship on Sunday — his first victory on the PGA Tour in five years and the 80th of his career.

Woods may have won the tournament, but the big winner was Justin Rose. The recently minted world No. 1 won the FedExCup and the $10 million bonus that comes along with it.

Our caddies were spectacular, with four picks finishing in the top 7, including Woods.

Here’s a look at how our caddies’ picks fared at East Lake:

Caddie 1

1. Webb Simpson, T4
2. Bubba Watson, 29th
3. Tiger Woods, Won

Caddie 2

1. Justin Thomas, T7
2. Brooks Koepka, T26
3. Xander Schauffele, T7

Caddie 3

1. Gary Woodland, T11
2. Webb Simpson, T4
3. Tiger Woods, Won

BMW Championship:

Unfortunately, weather plagued the BMW Championship — the third leg of the PGA Tour Playoffs for the FedExCup — but somehow they were able to squeeze in all 72 holes… even if it meant rolling over into Monday.

Keegan Bradley, the 2011 PGA Champion, was the eventual winner, taking down Justin Rose in a playoff.

Though none of our caddies had Bradley winning the tournament, they did identify two, top-6 finishers in Tiger Woods (T6) and Rose (runner up).

Here’s a look at how all the players our caddies picked fared:

Caddie 1

1. Justin Rose, 2
2. Bryson DeChambeau, T19
3. Tiger Woods, T6

Caddie 2

1. Dustin Johnson, T24
2. Patrick Reed, T19
3. Justin Thomas, T12

Caddie 3

1. Beau Hossler, T33
2. Bubba Watson, T16
3. Gary Woodland, T12

Dell Technologies Championship Results:

For the second week in a row, Bryson DeChambeau won on the PGA Tour. That makes him 2-for-2 in the FedEx Cup Playoffs with a commanding lead going into the BMW Championship this week in Philadelphia.

Our caddies didn’t pick DeChambeau to win again, but their picks were once again stellar. Two of our caddies selected Tony Finau. He tied for fourth. Two caddies also selected Dustin Johnson, who finished T7. Just outside the top 10 was Rory McIlroy at T12, another caddie pick.

Here’s a look at how all the players our caddies picked fared:

Caddie 1

1. Justin Thomas, T24
2. Tony Finau, T4
3. Rory McIlroy, T12

Caddie 2

1. Dustin Johnson, T7
2. Tony Finau, T4
3. Kelly Kraft, MC

Caddie 3

1. Justin Thomas, T24
2. Dustin Johnson, T7
3. Billy Horschel, WD

The Northern Trust Results:

Bryson DeChambeau captured the first leg of the PGA Tour Playoffs for the FedEx Cup with his convincing, four-stroke victory over Tony Finau in the Northern Trust at Ridgewood Country Club in Paramus, N.J., on Sunday.

Our caddies identified two, top-10 finishers this week in Justin Thomas (T8) and Brooks Koepka (T8).

Now the PGA Tour heads to TPC Boston in Norton, Mass., for the Dell Technologies Championship.

Here’s a look at how all the players our caddies picked fared:

Caddie 1

1. Justin Thomas, T8
2. Tiger Woods, T40
3. Troy Merritt, MC

Caddie 2

1. Brooks Koepka, T8
2. Dustin Johnson, T11
3. Kevin Na, T15

Caddie 3

1. Brandt Snedeker, MC
2. Matt Kuchar, T60
3. Zach Johnson, T40

Wyndham Championship Results:

Brandt Snedeker opened the Wyndham Championship in grand fashion on Thursday, firing an 11-under-par 59 — just the 10th sub-60 round in PGA Tour history.

RELATED: Caddie Travis Perkins talks Brandt Snedeker’s 11-under 59

On Sunday, he closed the tournament in style with a 5-under 65 and a three-stroke victory in the last event of the regular season. It was the fifth consecutive week that one of our caddies successfully picked a winner. Along with Snedeker, our caddies also picked Webb Simpson, who tied for second, and Brian Gay, who tied for sixth.

Here’s a look at how all the players our caddies picked finished this week.

Caddie 1

1. Harold Varner III, T53
2. Brian Gay, T6
3. Peter Uihlein, MC
4. Henrik Stenson, T20
5. Robert Garrigus, MC

Caddie 2

1. Sergio Garcia, T24
2. Bill Haas, T45
3. Webb Simpson, T2
4. Corey Conners, T45
5. Joaquin Niemann, T33

Caddie 3

1. Webb Simpson, T2
2. Henrik Stenson, T20
3. Davis Love III, MC
4. Julian Suri, T41
5. Brandt Snedeker, Won

PGA Championship Results:

Brooks Koepka withstood a spirited final-day charge by Tiger Woods (6-under 64) to win the PGA Championship at Bellerive on Sunday by two strokes. Koepka finished at 16-under 264. Woods finished alone in second, while Adam Scott was alone in third at 12 under.

For the fourth consecutive week, our caddie prognosticators identified the winner. Two of our caddies had Koepka winning. It was Koepka’s third major overall and his second this season, along with his successful defense of the U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills in June. He’s now halfway to a career grand slam.

Among our caddie picks, Justin Thomas was the only other top-10 finisher at the PGA Championship. He tied for sixth.

Caddie 1

1. Rory McIlroy, T50
2. Bubba Watson, MC
3. Tommy Fleetwood, T35
4. Rickie Fowler, T12
5. Jason Day, T19

Caddie 2

1. Dustin Johnson, T27
2. Justin Thomas, T6
3. Rory McIlroy, T50
4. Brooks Koepka, Won
5. Justin Rose, T19

Caddie 3

1. Brooks Koepka, Won
2. Dustin Johnson, T27
3. Rory McIlroy, T50
4. Tony Finau, T42
5. Jason Day, T19

WGC-Bridgestone Invitational Results:

Our caddies didn’t pick the winner at the WGC-Bridgestone Invitational this week, but they were stellar nonetheless, identifying four top-10 finishes.

Justin Thomas ultimately won at Firestone, a huge win as he heads to St. Louis this week for the defense of his PGA Championship victory a year ago. Dustin Johnson, a player all three of our caddies picked to win this past week, tied for third thanks to a 64 in the final round.

Rory McIlroy and Anirban Lahiri tied for sixth — two more of our caddie picks — while Tony Finau tied for 10th.

Caddie 1

1. Dustin Johnson, T3
2. Francesco Molinari, T39
3. Rory McIlroy, T6
4. Tiger Woods, T31
5. Xander Shauffele, 68

Caddie 2

1. Tony Finau, T10
2. Dustin Johnson, T3
3. Luke List, T24
4. Rory McIlroy, T6
5. Anirban Lahiri, T6

Caddie 3

1. Tiger Woods, T31
2. Dustin Johnson, T3
3. Tommy Fleetwood, T14
4. Justin Rose, WD
5. Gary Woodland, T17

Barracuda Championship Results:

For the third time in as many weeks, one of our caddies picked a winner… this time, it’s Andrew Putnam, who snagged his first career PGA Tour win at the Barracuda Championship in Reno on Sunday.

Other caddie picks finishing inside the top 10 were J.J. Spaun (T3), Chris Stroud (T7) and Brandon Harkins (T9).

Caddie 1

1. Tom Lovelady, T50
2. Ryan Blaum, WD
3. Joel Dahmen, T54
4. Abraham Ancer, DNS
5. J.J. Spaun, T3

Caddie 2

1. Scott Stallings, 22
2. Robert Garrigus, MC
3. Patrick Rodgers, T37
4. Ryan Palmer, T26
5. Chris Stroud, T7

Caddie 3

1. Shane Lowry, T15
2. Andrew Putnam, Won
3. Brandon Harkins, T9
4. Hunter Mahan, T23
5. Kevin Streelman, MC

RBC Canadian Open Results:

For the second week in a row, one of our caddies picked the winner of the tournament. This time around, it was Dustin Johnson finishing two shots clear of Whee Kim and Byeong Hun An. But that’s not all. Our caddies also identified two other top-10 finishers — Tommy Fleetwood (T6) and Joel Dahmen (T8).

Caddie 1

1. Joaquin Niemann, T37
2. Tony Finau, T37
3. Jhonattan Vegas, T29
4. Chez Reavie, MC
5. Tommy Fleetwood, T6

Caddie 2

1. Dustin Johnson, Win
2. Matt Kuchar, MC
3. J.B. Holmes, T61
4. Chad Campbell, T37
5. Jhonattan Vegas, T29

Caddie 3

1. Joel Dahmen, T8
2. Ben Silverman, T71
3. Nick Taylor, T71
4. Corey Conners, MC
5. J.T. Poston, MC

Open Championship Results: 

It was an impressive week for our caddies at the Open Championship. Along with picking the newest major champion – Francesco Molinari – our caddies also identified Rory McIlroy and Xander Shauffele, who tied for second, as well as Tiger Woods, who tied for sixth.

Caddie 1

1. Dustin Johnson, MC
2. Tiger Woods, T6
3. Rickie Fowler, T28
4. Rory McIlroy, T2
5. Tommy Fleetwood, T12

Caddie 2

1. Austin Cook, T28
2. Xander Shauffele, T2
3. Jordan Spieth, T9
4. Francesco Molinari, Winner
5. Rory McIlroy, T2

Caddie 3

1. Dustin Johnson, MC
2. Kevin Na, T51
3. Jon Rahm, MC
4. Rory McIlroy, T2
5. Brooks Koepka, T39

Barbasol Championship Results:

Over in Kentucky at the Barbasol Championship – which ran into Monday due to weather – our caddies had Billy Horschel (T2), Tom Lovelady (T2), J.T. Poston (fifth) and Brian Gay (sixth) among their picks for the week.

Caddie 1

1. Billy Horschel, T2
2. Joel Dahmen, T15
3. Tom Lovelady, T2
4. Brian Gay, 6
5. Josh Teater, T40

Caddie 2

1. Billy Horschel, T2
2. Joel Dahmen, T15
3. Whee Kim, T66
4. Andres Romero, T21
5. Chris Kirk, T40

Caddie 3

1. Joel Dahmen, T15
2. J.T. Poston, 5
3. Tyler Duncan, T49
4. Johnson Wagner, T31
5. Seamus Power, T34

John Deere Classic Results:

At the John Deere Classic, it was a mixed bag for our caddies, as four of their picks missed the cut, one withdrew and five of their collective picks finished inside the top 20.

Harold Varner III was the best of the bunch with his sixth-place showing. Kevin Streelman was next best. He fired a final-round 65 to tie for seventh.

Caddie 1

1. Zach Johnson, T16
2. Steve Stricker, T43
3. Bryson DeChambeau, WD
4. Joaquin Niemann, T23
5. Brian Gay, MC

Caddie 2

1. Kyle Stanley, MC
2. Harold Varner III, 6th
3. Steve Stricker, T43
4. Bryson DeChambeau, WD
5. Zach Johnson, T16

Caddie 3

1. Chez Reavie, MC
2. Bryson DeChambeau, WD
3. Zach Johnson, T16
4. Kevin Streelman, T7
5. Robert Streb, MC